As some of you are wondering, where in the world is Carmen Sandi Tamil Nadu?
It's the southernmost state in India. The location nearest us on this map is Kanchipuram (see in the northeast). India is divided into states as is the United States, but an important difference is that this subcontinent is polyglot: Indians speak a large variety of languages.
Imagine that they spoke German in Georgia, French in Florida, and Albanian in Alabama. That's a bit what it's like here. If we cross over the northern border of Tamil Nadu into Andhra Pradesh, say, we hear Telugu. Just to the west in Karnataka, it's a language called Kannada. To our southwest in Kerala, they speak Mayalam.
Hindi is another Indian language, but it's more widely spoken as the official language in eleven states in the north (including Delhi).
As you may expect, we speak Tamil in Tamil Nadu. Unfortunately the "we" is not exactly inclusive, although I try (a little) in fits and starts. Currently I'm on a months-long hiatus, during which I haven't cracked the book. It's disappointing to not be able to communicate better after spending so much time in the country.
But Rising Star is officially an "English medium school" and the children and staff need above all to hear it spoken properly. So it's really a duty not to practice terribly broken Tamil on everyone. And this is all exacerbated by the fact that Tamil boasts no fewer than 247 letters and comes in many variants. There are several dialects, a classical written form, a modern written form, and a modern spoken form.
If I ask three children how to say a word as simple as "house," I'll hear three different answers. Or sometimes there are so many ways to say a word (this happened with "tired") that the person I'm asking will declare that it is untranslatable.
But sitting in on occasional sessions of first-grade Tamil class has done wonders, and I can decipher (=pronounce, not comprehend!) some of its beautifully coiled floral shapes. My favorite thing about reading Tamil is that, although it is usually read left to right, you sometimes read a few letters right to left within the word. Sounds like a code!
It's the southernmost state in India. The location nearest us on this map is Kanchipuram (see in the northeast). India is divided into states as is the United States, but an important difference is that this subcontinent is polyglot: Indians speak a large variety of languages.
Imagine that they spoke German in Georgia, French in Florida, and Albanian in Alabama. That's a bit what it's like here. If we cross over the northern border of Tamil Nadu into Andhra Pradesh, say, we hear Telugu. Just to the west in Karnataka, it's a language called Kannada. To our southwest in Kerala, they speak Mayalam.
Hindi is another Indian language, but it's more widely spoken as the official language in eleven states in the north (including Delhi).
As you may expect, we speak Tamil in Tamil Nadu. Unfortunately the "we" is not exactly inclusive, although I try (a little) in fits and starts. Currently I'm on a months-long hiatus, during which I haven't cracked the book. It's disappointing to not be able to communicate better after spending so much time in the country.
But Rising Star is officially an "English medium school" and the children and staff need above all to hear it spoken properly. So it's really a duty not to practice terribly broken Tamil on everyone. And this is all exacerbated by the fact that Tamil boasts no fewer than 247 letters and comes in many variants. There are several dialects, a classical written form, a modern written form, and a modern spoken form.
If I ask three children how to say a word as simple as "house," I'll hear three different answers. Or sometimes there are so many ways to say a word (this happened with "tired") that the person I'm asking will declare that it is untranslatable.
But sitting in on occasional sessions of first-grade Tamil class has done wonders, and I can decipher (=pronounce, not comprehend!) some of its beautifully coiled floral shapes. My favorite thing about reading Tamil is that, although it is usually read left to right, you sometimes read a few letters right to left within the word. Sounds like a code!

